Note: This is an incomplete list, particularly in the early years of Tahquitz Lodge. This list may never be complete. Some information is speculative. If you have further information, please Contact Us.
| Year / Term | Lodge Chief | Lay Adviser |
| 1938 – 1939 | Charles Berry | |
| 1939 – 1940 | Ralph Wright | |
| 1940 – 1941 | ||
| 1941 – 1942 | ||
| 1942 – 1943 | ||
| 1943 – 1944 | ||
| 1944 – 1945 | Jim Harris | |
| 1945 – 1946 | Tom McClelland | |
| 1946 – 1947 | John Herring (1928 – 2003) | |
| 1947 – 1948 | Kerby Hester (1926 – 2003) | |
| 1948 – 1949 | ||
| 1949 – 1950 | ||
| 1950 – 1951 | Frank Simpkins (1932 – 2013) | |
| 1951 – 1952 | Rodney Newcomb | |
| 1952 – 1953 | Chuck Pierce (1935 – 2009) | |
| 1953 – 1954 | Ed Klure | |
| 1954 – 1955 | Ken Kammeyer | |
| 1955 – 1956 | Tom Watsons | Claude Coltrain (1908 – 1966) |
| 1956 – 1957 | John Klure | |
| 1957 – 1958 | Don Fitzloff (1941 – 2019) | |
| 1958 – 1959 | Dave White | Tom Pierce |
| 1959 – 1960 | Lee Ellis | |
| 1960 – 1961 | Ed Shea | |
| 1961 – 1962 | Bob Pepper | Sam Tate |
| 1962 – 1963 | Ted Fitzpatrick | Bob White |
| 1963 – 1964 | John Larocca | Dave Peterson |
| 1964 – 1965 | Ron Richmond | Dave Peterson |
| 1965 – 1966 | John Nauman | |
| 1966 – 1967 | George Harris | |
| 1967 – 1968 | Joe Artino | |
| 1968 – 1969 | Mo Gotcher | Jim Montgomery |
| 1969 – 1970 | Kim Wilkinson | Jim Montgomery |
| 1970 – 1971 | Terry Tyson | Jim Montgomery |
| 1971 – 1972 | Michael Cheley | Harley Tyson |
| 1972 – 1973 | Jon Nelson | Harley Tyson |